Skip to content
ARDOR SEO

Should You Buy Real Estate Leads? Do the Math Before You Pay

By Kris Reid ·Updated

Buying real estate leads is worth it when your cost per closing is well below the commission you keep after your broker split. Work it out before you pay: price per lead, the share you reach, the share who meet you and the share who close. Most agents who lose money on bought leads lose it on slow response and short follow-up, not on the price.

Every lead vendor answers this question with “yes, if you follow up.” That’s true, but it doesn’t tell you whether a particular source will pay for itself in your market. Below is the math, with real vendor prices from their own pages as of October 2026, plus a 90-day test you can run on any source. For a list of the companies themselves, see our comparison of real estate lead generation companies.

Woman looking at a laptop, thinking about whether to buy real estate leads

Is buying real estate leads worth it?

Buying real estate leads is worth it if one formula comes out in your favor: total spend divided by closings must be lower than your net commission per deal, with room left over for your time. That’s the whole decision.

The formula has four inputs you control or can measure:

  1. Cost per lead (or per connection, depending on what the vendor sells)
  2. Contact rate: the share of leads you actually speak with
  3. Appointment rate: the share of contacted leads who meet you or sign a buyer agreement
  4. Close rate: the share of appointments that close within 12 months

Multiply the three rates together and you get your lead-to-close rate. Divide your cost per lead by that rate and you have your cost per closing. A cheap lead with a terrible contact rate can cost more per closing than an expensive one you reach every time.

How much do real estate leads cost in 2026?

Real estate leads cost anywhere from a few cents for a skip-traced phone number to a few hundred dollars for a live buyer connection. Vendors sell very different things under the word “lead,” so compare what you’re actually getting. These prices are from each vendor’s own page, checked in October 2026.

Vendor What you get Published price
Zillow Premier Agent Buyer connections by live call, email, tour request or pre-approved buyer Varies by market; average cost per connection $223 in major metros, $139 in non-major metros
Real Geeks Website and CRM platform, plus optional ad-driven lead packages Platform $399/month (two users) plus a $500 one-time setup fee; social package $299/month (about 20 to 40 buyer leads a month); search package $599/month (about 20 to 40 buyer leads); seller package $599/month (about 10 to 15 seller leads). Lead counts are estimates that depend on market tier
REDX Contact data for expireds, FSBOs, FRBOs, pre-foreclosures and neighborhood lists $60/month per lead type, or $199/month for the Core bundle (all five lead types plus skip tracing); annual plans cost less
Realtor.com ReadyConnect Concierge Leads screened by Realtor.com’s team and passed to agents No upfront cost; you pay a referral fee on closed transactions. The fee percentage isn’t published on the page

Two warnings. First, REDX-style data isn’t an inquiry: those homeowners didn’t ask to hear from you, so you’re prospecting, and the calling rules below apply. Second, vendor lead counts are the vendor’s estimates. Realtor.com’s page, for example, says its leads convert “up to 3-5x” better than average, citing its own internal data from 2019.

Team around a wooden table with laptops, tablets and notebooks planning a lead strategy

How do you calculate cost per closing for real estate leads?

Calculate cost per closing by dividing everything you spent on a source, including platform fees, by the number of closings it produced within a year. Then compare that number with your net commission per deal.

Use the same worksheet for any source. Our guide to setting a real estate marketing budget shows how to track cost per closing across all your channels, and our real estate lead generation statistics explain why no trustworthy public benchmark exists for lead-to-close rates.

Pay per lead or referral fee: which model is better?

Pay-per-lead suits agents with cash and a strong follow-up system; referral-fee models suit agents with little cash who close well. The difference is when you pay and how much of the upside you give away.

Question Pay per lead or monthly package Referral fee at closing
When you pay Every month, whether or not anything closes Only when a deal closes
Risk You carry it The vendor carries most of it
Cost on a closed deal Your cost per closing (often a few thousand dollars) A share of your commission, set in the referral agreement
Best for Agents who reach leads fast and nurture for a year Newer agents, or agents testing a new market
Watch for Long contracts, setup fees, lead counts that are estimates Fee percentage, how long the fee applies, whether it covers the client’s future deals

A quick illustration: if a referral agreement took 35% (an illustrative figure, not any vendor’s rate) of the $10,000 gross commission in the example above, that single deal would cost $3,500 in fees, more than the $2,495 pay-per-lead cost per closing. If the pay-per-lead agent’s contact rate were poor, the referral model would win. Read any referral agreement with your broker before you sign.

Is buying leads from Realtor.com or Zillow worth it?

Buying leads from Realtor.com or Zillow is worth it in markets where you can respond within minutes and your cost per closing beats your net commission. Neither company publishes close rates you can rely on for your own market, so the only real answer is a tracked test.

The two work differently. Zillow Premier Agent sells connections, and its page says price varies by market, home values and expected connections. Realtor.com’s Concierge program screens leads first and charges a referral fee only when a deal closes. Portal leads are often shopping several agents at once, which is why our guide to speed to lead in real estate matters more for portal leads than for any other source.

Why do bought real estate leads fail?

Bought real estate leads mostly fail for three reasons: slow first contact, follow-up that stops after a week, and no tracking. All three are fixable.

  • Slow first contact. If the lead filled in the same form for several agents, the first one to call usually gets the conversation.
  • Short follow-up. Many online inquiries are months from a move. Agents who stop after three calls throw away the leads they paid for. Our real estate lead follow-up guide gives a cadence for portal leads out to 12 months.
  • No tracking. Without a source tag on every lead and an outcome on every closing, you can’t tell which vendor is paying and which is draining you.

How do you run a 90-day test before committing?

Run a 90-day test by fixing the budget, tagging every lead, and reviewing contact and appointment rates monthly. Then keep nurturing the leads for a full year before you judge closings.

  • Pick one source and one budget you can afford to lose.
  • Ask the vendor for the shortest contract and confirm cancellation terms in writing.
  • Create a CRM source tag and route every lead from the source into it.
  • Set a response target, such as a call within five minutes during working hours.
  • Record contact, appointment, agreement and closing for every lead.
  • At day 30, 60 and 90, calculate contact rate and appointment rate.
  • At day 90, decide: continue, renegotiate or stop. Keep nurturing every test lead either way.
  • At month 12, calculate cost per closing including late closings.

What are the alternatives to buying real estate leads?

The main alternatives to buying leads are working your sphere, earning search traffic, and getting in front of other people’s audiences. They cost less in cash and more in time, and they keep working after you stop paying.

For a ranking of every channel, see our guide on how to get real estate leads.

Team members stacking their hands together over a meeting table

Sources

  1. Zillow Premier Agent, Zillow (accessed October 14, 2026)
  2. Real Geeks Pricing, Real Geeks (accessed October 14, 2026)
  3. REDX Pricing, REDX (accessed October 14, 2026)
  4. ReadyConnect Concierge, Realtor.com (accessed October 14, 2026)
  5. Q&A for Telemarketers & Sellers About DNC Provisions in TSR, Federal Trade Commission (accessed October 14, 2026)
  6. Stop Unwanted Robocalls and Texts, Federal Communications Commission (accessed October 14, 2026)

Frequently asked questions

How long does it take for bought real estate leads to close?

Many buyers who inquire online are months away from a purchase, so a 90-day test will show contact and appointment rates long before it shows closings. Keep nurturing every test lead for at least a year and count late closings against the original spend.

Are exclusive real estate leads better than shared leads?

Exclusive leads go only to you, so you aren't racing other agents, but they usually cost more. Shared leads can still work if you respond within minutes. Compare them on cost per closing, not price per lead.

What is a good cost per closing for bought leads?

There is no universal benchmark. Compare your cost per closing with your average net commission after your broker split and fees. Our rule of thumb: if a source's cost per closing is more than about a third of what you keep, it rarely pays once your time is counted.

Kris Reid

Kris Reid

Founder & CEO, Ardor SEO; Co-Founder & CEO, Icons of Real Estate

Kris Reid founded Ardor SEO in 2010 after a career in software engineering with major banks. He co-founded Icons of Real Estate, a podcast network for real estate professionals, and has been a guest on more than 100 podcasts.